Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Stevan Fairburn's avatar

The useful boundary here is that evidence synthesis and point-of-care answering are not the same evaluation task.

For clinical AI, I would want the benchmark to preserve the workflow shape: what source was retrieved, whether the question was educational or action-facing, what uncertainty remained, and which human role still owned the decision.

In surgery, that distinction matters because a tool that helps a learner organize evidence can be valuable even when it should not be allowed to convert that evidence into a readiness claim or a change in room workflow.

No posts

Ready for more?